Colin Kaepernick has done it now.  His recent acts of protest  – as expected – have many “patriotic” Americans going mad.  In an effort to call attention to various injustices in society, particularly police brutality, Kaepernick, a national football league player, takes a knee and refuses to stand for the national anthem at the beginning of each his games.  Sportscasters and analysts have talked about this incessantly and the protest has grown with many athletes of different levels and sports joining this call to action. As we all know, the American flag which waves during the singing of the anthem has long symbolized ‘liberty and justice for all.’  However, many believe this symbol is unfulfilled.  The chorus of “he’s disrespectful to our military”, “he should leave the country”, “he should lose his job”, and worse, speaks volumes about the folks who think he is dishonoring a flag in a country where he makes millions of dollars to play football. To me, I see the opposite; Kaepernick is honoring the ideals of the flag more than all of us.
To those who proclaim to be protecting the honor of the flag by condemning Kaepernick, it would be nice if they consider a small thing called perspective.  I wonder if they have ever considered how they’re disrespecting the flag? I could begin with the fact that if they’re not standing up in silent reverence, hand over their heart, tear in their eye, everywhere and anytime they hear the national anthem (even in their home), they may want to rethink their critique.  Plus, when did the military become the lone representation of patriotism in our country? Are “regular” citizens not able to express these ideals of freedom? Colin Kaepernick is within his rights to not stand for the national anthem.  He is not in violation of any law but is simply choosing to not participate in a custom.  One is disrespecting the honor of this country by telling him he doesn’t have a right to not observe a custom. Although his objectives are vague, it is obvious that Kaepernick is touching a nerve.  He has caused Americans to discuss race and resistance.  He has people reconsidering patriotism and protest.  Most importantly, he has challenged all those who condemn riots and destructive protests with a simple nonviolent gesture expressing an opinion that America isn’t living to its highest ideal.
This issue (that is still unfolding) is one of the key challenges this country faces; finding a normative definition of freedom.  Customary expressions of freedom are a societal norm but it is also a relative paradigm. See, freedom is quite fluid, assumed by the majority yet elusive for the minority. It has a subjectivity that’s as abstract as it is tangible.  Since the beginning of our country, certain groups have maintained and controlled the norms and definitions of society, mostly to their benefit. But, in this day and age, in a society that’s freer than it’s ever been, many are challenging any norms that make them feel less than American.   Critics of Kaepernick need to recognize that freedom means different things to different people and the flag represents an American right to pursue the purest form of freedom.  If one’s feelings are hurt by his nonviolent gesture, they should explore why. Kaepernick is exercising the fullest expression of the flag by thoughtfully demanding more from it.  By trying to subjectively limit what (and who) the flag stands for, his critics are the ones who are disrespecting it and limiting its potential.  We ALL own this symbol thus we must always pursue its highest ideals.